Agile HR + Talent Leadership + Technology Questions

Ask a question


The process of evaluating employee performance can be taxing on managers who don't understand or see the value in them. And unfortunately, most managers see performance reviews as bureaucratic admin work forced onto them by HR.

Here are some common mistakes managers make whilst completing performance reviews:

1. Confuse excellence with growth. Performance is different than growth. If you're evaluating growth, then you cannot neglect information or data that has been collected during the previous years for that specific position.

2. Too vague in responses. Avoid general statements, especially when judging an employees performance or talking about compensation during evaluation. The message you send to the employee should consist of specific things they're doing right, how they've already improved, and what they can do to grow.

3. Not listing measurable goals. Letting the employee walk away without a set of tracks or pathways to improve defeats the purpose of having a performance review in the first place. Don't forget to give them the opportunity and direction to measure their goals and achievements for next time.

4. Treating the evaluation process as a one-way street. It's a great idea to tell employees how their work is impacting the company's general goals, value, and culture. It's also important to remember that they are a huge part of the dialogue in performance evaluations. The most effective evaluations include a discussion with the employee.

Your Answer

Please login first to submit.

Talentsocket Questions is a Q&A site for HR, talent, and technology pros. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Help this community grow.

Ask a Question

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of Katie Conde
Profile picture of Ruby Pethebridge
Profile picture of don
Profile picture of Tayla Symon
Profile picture of Kristy Keegan
Profile picture of Clint May
Profile picture of edwardmc
Profile picture of Luella Neel
Profile picture of Cyril Collazo
Profile picture of Michael
Profile picture of Natasha Taormina
Profile picture of Desiree Doe
Profile picture of Doretha Box
Profile picture of Kassandra Wardill
Profile picture of Fabian Hutchins
Profile picture of Manie Rempe
Download this free report!

27 Awesome Email Templates
Every HR Pro Needs

Years of HR email experience put together in one simple package.
free for Talentsocket Members